Simply Vib’s Babbling - God of the Gaps

My Jetstream pen costs me $1.85 and the refill costs $1.75. My question: should I be getting a refill or a new pen? I ponder over such questions frequently, often wondering if what we normally consider good value bundles or stuff that are ‘worth the price’ are truly good purchases. I figured out that we need to think about the value the goods offer us. If something offers zero value and yet comes at a cost, it is not wise to make the purchase at all. This is especially true for bundles. For example, I am offered to buy 100 Lipton Tea Bags at $7 and the package comes with a free mug. Should I take it up if I need the 100 Tea Bags but the mug would only take up extra space in my house without being used at all and 50 Tea Bags comes at a price of $3?

Basic math and cost-benefit analysis suggests that if I value the cup at more than $1 then I should buy the package. Unfortunately, most people would just consider ‘When would I get another opportunity to get a Lipton limited edition mug for $1?’ It is obviously the wrong question to ask. And that’s why I opt to get the refill. While I know that the pen casing with the spring and the clicking mechanism in the Jetstream pen probably cost more than 10 cents or comes close to being around 10 cents, it is a question of how much I value it. Since I can’t use the pen casing without a refill it’s value is zero and so I’d rather buy a refill that helps save me 10 cents.

2 COMMENTS
oneiros
February 9, 2010
ad

I think there is an issue with your pricing of the Lipton Tea Bags
- 50 tea bags for $3
- 100 tea bags for $7? (will probably cost less than 6)

The question usually is, should I stock up on the Lipton Tea Bags I have at a slight discount (+free mug), or not?

Also, you have not set up the conditions of your getting a new pen/refill: did your current pen run out of ink, or are you anticipating its occurrence? Because if it is in anticipation – ill say that 10cents has value – for the deployability of your additional pen/refill (yes, the casing has no value without the refill, but you will not use the refill without a casing either). Also, what if you lose your current pen?

Also, I don’t think it is about its relative value to you, but its absolute value – you have simply implicitly factored in the assumption that you will not attempt to resell your pen casing/refill.

February 9, 2010
ad

Well, there’s no issue with the pricing actually, I’m trying to set up a simpler problem than what you suggested. In the event when you need only 50 tea-bags and then 100 tea-bags are going at a discount with the free mug then I think you should only get it if the discount is large enough to induce you to get 100 instead of 50 (ignore the mug totally if it has no value to you).

With regards to the pen, I’m talking about when you’re out of ink. In any case I do think that reselling it will cause me more hassle than 10 cents. If it’s the absolute value than the casing definitely is worth something but then you’re just making a loss when you keep it without doing anything with it (and plus the hassle of resale is more than 10 cents).

Post a comment